Thrift Stores Don't Want Your Cheap Clothes

Oct 26, 2007 @ 4:26pm

kate dress 2.jpg
Lisa Armstrong reports from London today that Oxfam is turning down cheap-chic offerings, with this explanation:

"Say you bought [an outfit] in a [chain store] for £3. And let’s assume, for politeness’ sake, that you wore it just the once. On the assumption that most clothes devalue by 50 per cent the moment you take them out of the bag, and by another 50 per cent once they’ve been worn, shoved in the back of the wardrobe, slammed into a bin liner and left to fester for a few seasons, the most Oxfam could charge would be 75p."
That's $1.50 to us.

Lisa raises a few interesting concerns. She reminds us, again, that some cheap clothes are harder to recycle (thanks to that nylon poly blend described on the label), while also hinting the changing face of the thrift store customer:

It used to be that chain stores were for those with more money, and thrift stores were where you went when you couldn't quite afford The Gap. At least, that's where we went, in middle school and high school, when we couldn't.

Now the shopping setup shifts, with chain stores offering the cheapest stuff, and thrift stores becoming "vintage boutiques" and - for the most part - catering to a more fashion focused group.

One more thing to think about:

The head of Oxfam, Jane Shepherdson, was once the head of TopShop, and she's the one largely held responsible for making cheap chic into the norm.

But even if her charity stores in Britain won't accept the clothes she helped create, we bet American thrift stores would - do you know how many US teenagers would kill for a TopShop dress?

Comments

avatar

posted by olya

Oct 26, 2007 4:45PM

is it me or is the first sentence in that quote not understandable?

avatar

posted by Annmarie

Oct 26, 2007 5:06PM

It makes more sense if you read the sentence before it in the article.

avatar

posted by cindy

Oct 26, 2007 6:51PM

Thriftstores really are becoming fancy.. the other day i went to Savers and they wanted $69 for a pair of vintage Zodiac boots that i used to be able to get for $5!

avatar

posted by Alphi

Oct 26, 2007 6:56PM

So true. I used to volunteer at the Housing Works Thrift Store on W 10th and we literally just had bags full of cheap clothes that we sent out to the warehouse because they simply don't sell. We only kept the really cool vintage and designer stuff.

avatar

posted by Ana

Oct 27, 2007 8:09AM

you guys glamourise topshop a bit too much

avatar

posted by hmm

Oct 27, 2007 9:18AM

im sure the starving kids who need every penny couldnt give a hoot whether its high street or high end. seems like these days charities are becoming less and less credible

avatar

posted by DC Goodwill Fashionista

Oct 27, 2007 11:38AM

As long as it's free of tears, stains, holes, and smells, Goodwill stores will accept any clothing donations. I think it's okay to have standards, but let's not forget that many thrift stores are largely designed to provide affordable clothing and wares to lower-income folks. For those of us who can afford to shop elsewhere, but choose to go thrifting (in the true sense of the word, NOT at the City Opera "Thrift" Shop on E 23rd!), finding treasure as such great prices is part of the fun. And I'm willing to sift through cheap clothes from London anyday!

avatar

posted by Nicole Bremner

Oct 27, 2007 1:49PM

Thanks for flagging up Lisa's article (oh I miss the Times now I live in NYC). I've been banging on about ethical shopping for a while and not just organic or manufacturing but the long lifespan of quality clothing. While old news now, it's also important to consider where the clothes have been made, conditions for workers and the airmiles used to transport it. And of course you look and feel so much better when you're clothing is a good cut and fabric.

avatar

posted by Sarah

Oct 28, 2007 2:02PM

You think US girls would kill for TopShop anything? Please! I agree with Ana.

avatar

posted by guest

Oct 28, 2007 8:07PM

is that dress still on sale or is it sold out?

avatar

posted by Cynthia C

Oct 29, 2007 10:56AM

I love thrift shops, vintage shops and consignment sales (I'm actually going to one in Toronto this weekend. If anyone wants to check it out, the website for it is:http://www.trunkspaceconsignment.com ) My mom would have a fit, though, especially for vintage. She's like "what if someone died in it?" I think it's cultural (Mom is from Hong Kong.)

avatar

posted by a

Oct 29, 2007 11:04AM

I know it's a rhetorical point, but the ending of this post makes no sense. The original article is about the UK (and about more low end stores like Primark, not Topshop) and people dumping their cheap clothes after one wear. Nobody is going to trek used Topshop or Primark stuff to the US to donate to thrift stores!

avatar

posted by brendastarlet

Oct 29, 2007 11:32AM

I completely understand why the London shops don't want cheap fashions. A good portion of what all thrift shops receive is not resaleable.

That's not because it's out of fashion, but because the stuff was in terrible shape when it arrived. It not only gets sent to a warehouse, but is then sold by the warehouse to companies that buy garments by the pound and ship them abroad, or send them to be made into rags.

About the only thing you can count on when you donate is that it's being taken off your hands, and you get a tax receipt. Hopefully some deserving person gets a nice garment to wear, but if it was wrecked when you donated it, you can bet it's going to the warehouse.

avatar

posted by Nia

Oct 29, 2007 12:33PM

Where is that dress from, I love it!

avatar

posted by a

Oct 30, 2007 8:58AM

It's Kate Moss for Topshop.

Post Your Comment