It Ain’t Easy Being Green

plas bag.jpg

This article on “Green Fatigue” in today’s Independent really struck a nerve with us - it’s all about how the relentless marketing of marginally environmentally-friendly products has worn down consumers, who have become skeptical about the real impact of their individual purchases on global warming and other environmental issues.

We’ve been feeling secretly guilty for a long time about how apathetic we’ve become about eco-friendly fashion. We’re all for designers using organic cotton, but we can’t get excited in the least about Loomstate for Barneys.

We hate plastic bags too, but even if they don’t get stuck in trees and destroy the world, the “I’m Not A Plastic Bag” totes are annoyingly omnipresent.

And here’s what the experts have to say:

“”The problems we face are of a magnitude no one has seen in at least two generations,” says Alex Steffen, the executive editor of WorldChanging, a website and book that promote innovative solutions for sustainable living. “The scale of the actions people are being told to take by green consumerism groups and businesses, on the other hand, are so small as to seem meaningless. I think that more and more people see this widening gulf and lose hope.”

And if we’re not all losing hope just yet, many of us are becoming increasingly cynical. To campaigners, that’s not surprising. As Steffen suggests, businesses have turned environmentalism into a marketing strategy. A new term, “green-washing”, describes companies that paint a superficial green gloss on conventional business practices. When firms such as BP and Wal-Mart parade their environmentally friendly credentials, skepticism is not only inevitable, says Steffen, it’s “a necessary antidote”.”

Do you see eco-conscious design as a marketing strategy, or do you still believe that one dress can make a difference?

—ALISON COOL

Comments

avatar
1

posted by pcat

Sep 20, 2007 2:16PM

It's unfortunate that all this eco-conscious marketing is turning people off to the real issues but i understand the fatigue. However, taking the best environmentally-conscious actions that fit your lifestyle is better than doing nothing at all. It's not about being socially-acceptable or fashionable, it's about self-preservation for the long term, people!

avatar
2

posted by Sally

Sep 20, 2007 2:25PM

I am fatigued by it, and by the pretentious people who buy the Hindmarch bag, but they think twice about solar panels on their roof because they are ugly.

Now, the political theorist in me would say that environmentalism as a marketing campaign is the best way around the problem. The model we have is a capitalist one, where consumption is key, and if the way we get out of it is through what we know, then that will have to do. We can't just create a new way of thinking, and so we do it by referencing what we already know to find another strategy. Which in this case, happens to be marketing. Not quite deconstruction, but I can live with it.

avatar
3

posted by tahl

Sep 20, 2007 2:35PM

I think the problem with Anya Hindmarch's bag is that it's become a PURSE, rather than an alternative for your groceries (its original intention). That's what I find annoying.

avatar
4

posted by WendyB

Sep 20, 2007 3:49PM

Whew, I'm glad someone else has finally said it. I'm worn out by it all. Though I certainly believe in taking care of the environment, I'm overwhelmed and turned off. It's kind of like breast cancer awareness. Even though I'm related to one survivor and was close to someone who died quite young of the disease (and regularly go for mammograms), the relentless emphasis on it seems to have a lot of women thinking that they are doomed to die of breast cancer...it's too much.

avatar
5

posted by MH

Sep 20, 2007 5:07PM

I think the marketing fatigue is actually a step in the right direction. To truly conserve and reduce our impact, we shouldn't be buying Anya Hindmarch totes. We should be digging those $20 Urban Outfitters canvas totes from middle school out of the closet and carrying them to the grocery store. Or even just realizing, "Hey, my $600 oversize tote could fit a small toddler, maybe I'll put all my dry foods in there and carry the eggs and milk home in just one bag." If you're going to make a new purchase anyway, then green or organic goods are something to consider, but purchasing less is really the key.

My personal mission this summer was to skip both the lines at Whole Foods in Union Square for the bags AND the lines at Forever 21 next door--instead of buying something new every time I needed an outfit, I was going to wear everything in my closet at least once. I was embarassed to find out how much great stuff there really was--it's already September and there are STILL dresses in my closet that haven't even had the tags taken off, and I started this in June. We have to look at our current lives before we start filling them up with more stuff.

avatar
6

posted by Nihaopengyo

Sep 20, 2007 9:49PM

Going "Green" is important to all of us. I thin carrying a bag that I can put my purchases in and leave the stores plastic bags at the store is great.

Nihao

http://www.redlanternstyle.com

avatar
7

posted by guest

Sep 21, 2007 12:17AM

If it makes anyone feel better about not being super-green, we could possibly be coming out of an ice age, and nothing you do could stop global warming because it's a natural process (at least in part).

avatar
8

posted by anisa

Sep 21, 2007 10:51AM

Thank You for that artical. I design for a small fashion company in Portland, OR. We have just put out our first "eco/sustainable" line. Although, the fabrics are soft and we are very happy with them, good design is our first goal.
My main concern in the fashion world is that people seem to be only caring about the fabric content. How "green" can your company be if you use organic fabrics, but everything is made overseas and you use the same frieght shipping company as Walmart?

That being said, it's great for people to be in this mindset. Going green is a good thing!

xo~anisa

http://www.makoollovesyou.com

avatar
9

posted by chartreuse girl

Sep 21, 2007 12:30PM

Hey, light green is better than not green at all, right? Maybe the Anya bag's just being carried as a status symbol, but if it gets just a few people thinking about their plastic bag use, isn't that better than carrying around a Birkin? A green life is a mental thing: staying conscious of ways reduce your impact that work for your income, your style, and your life.

Also, who cares if eco fashion is a fad right now. Think of recycling, or getting rid of the holes in the ozone... Those used to be pet projects, but you know what? Now they've been incorporated into daily life. I wouldn't be surprised if the trendy push for eco clothing gets the industry to permanently rethink how it does business.

avatar
10

posted by sf_citybird

Sep 22, 2007 3:14AM

best thing you can do for the environment is stop shopping...or at least buy less.

avatar
11

posted by Nihaopengyo

Sep 24, 2007 7:43PM

I would like to think I could stop shopping....but I know that is not going to happen. So I had better help the environment in other ways.

Nihao

http://www.redlanternstyle.com

Post Your Comment