Would Sienna Sell?

Jun 04, 2007 @ 3:22pm

keiras in bed.jpg
Over the weekend, we were sent an interesting email:

An allegation that Sienna Miller was meant to be Coco Mademoiselle's new face, and for various reasons - mostly the starlet's flaming and occasionally flamed-out image - Ms. Miller was replaced by Keira Knightley.

Chanel flatly denies the rumor, telling us, "This is a completely false statement," and Keira does seem to be a phenomenal face for the brand (maybe even a perfect one), especially since Chanel Mademoiselle is our favorite scent from the canon, and we saw Pride and Prejudice twice this weekend because it was that good.

Still, the email made us wonder:

Would we rather embody Sienna's style or Keira's? And what brands, if any, should Sienna represent?

We think a good sunglass company would be crazy not to sign her...

posted by Laia

Jun 04, 2007 3:49PM

Whos that girl on the bottom?
As much as I dont care for Keira, I think she'd be better if anything because Sienna's a bit overexposed and no one cares about her anymore.

posted by HeatherChandler

Jun 04, 2007 3:52PM

Sienna Miller - Night Train

posted by Faran

Jun 04, 2007 3:56PM

Um, that girl on the bottom is Sienna Miller from W Magazine...

posted by Laia

Jun 04, 2007 4:02PM

yeah, i realized it was a stupid question, but i seriously looked at it and i couldnt recognize her and all... she looks like scarlett johanssen's skinnier cousin?
weird.

posted by guest

Jun 04, 2007 4:21PM

she does like scarlett!

posted by Jenny

Jun 04, 2007 4:21PM

Keira, hands down... she seems naturally sexy whereas Sienna seems much too made up. That picture does remind my of Scarlett Johansson, esp. her Vogue pics.

posted by missryanm

Jun 04, 2007 4:43PM

oh! oh! wasn't this a blind item? is sienna the actress who lost out on a modeling contract with a top agency because of her partying ways? (!)

posted by Faran

Jun 04, 2007 4:46PM

NO, absolutely not the same.

posted by scarlettholly

Jun 04, 2007 4:58PM

Sienna already is the face of Pepe jeans, which is a bit random. Not exactly Chanel. Is she the face of her clothing line (I forget the name - something to do with numbers?)?

posted by missryanm

Jun 04, 2007 5:17PM

darn.

posted by Phoebe

Jun 04, 2007 7:15PM

Might I say that Sienna looks notably trashy in that picture?

In any case, I prefer Keira. I think Keira and Sienna's fashion sense is equally debatable, because we have seen both horrid and wonderful pieces on both of them. However, Coco Mademoiselle is made for a classy girl, which, I think, Keira embodies much more so than Sluttyienna.

posted by Rachel

Jun 04, 2007 7:52PM

I like Sienna a lot but I definitely don't see her as a face for Chanel. I was never a fan of Keira until this month's Vogue, so I think she's a good choice.

And Sienna is DEF channeling Scarlett--the face of Louis Vuitton--is she really trying to go high fashion or what?

posted by Jen

Jun 04, 2007 8:41PM

I think Kiera would make a great face for Chanel.

posted by guest

Jun 05, 2007 12:21AM

neither?

posted by Anoymous

Jun 05, 2007 11:43AM

It was always Keira....wait till u see the film / commercial....Baz Luhrmann?

posted by hm

Jun 05, 2007 2:20PM

although i do not like kiera, i dont think sienna would have been a good choice. i chanel girl needs to be more classic beauty and elegance and i personally think a dark haired women would do the trick much more than a blonde in the first place

posted by guest

Jun 05, 2007 3:20PM

i really don't like sienna, and I don't think she would make a better face for chanel the keira. However, i don't think keira is a good choice either...

posted by guest

Jun 06, 2007 9:59AM

the director of pride and prejudice directed the commercial.